Software testing methodologies are the processes and procedures used to test software applications. These methodologies can range from manual testing using a checklist of pre-defined tests to automated testing using specialised tools. Each methodology has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, but they all have the same goal: uncovering bugs in the code before it goes live. 

Many software testing methodologies exist, but which one is right for you? And how do you know if a methodology is a right fit in the first place? This ebook will explore the basics of software testing methodologies and help you decide which is best for your next project. 

Types of Methodologies

Each methodology has its unique approach to testing. Here are common software testing methodologies:

Waterfall Model

The waterfall model is also referred to as a linear-sequential life cycle model. It divides the software development process into distinct phases, such as requirements gathering and testing. This model works well for smaller projects with clearly-defined objectives but can be difficult to manage on large-scale projects. The waterfall model can be classified into phases: requirement analysis, analysis, design, code, testing, and maintenance.

Advantages of the Waterfall Model

  • The biggest advantage of the waterfall model is that it provides a clear roadmap for the project from start to finish.
  • It also ensures that each step has been completed before moving on to the next, making it a great choice for projects that require tight control.

Disadvantages of the Waterfall Model

  • One of the biggest drawbacks of the waterfall model is that it does not allow for changes or modifications once a phase has been completed. This can make adapting to changes in the environment or customer requirements difficult.
  • Additionally, it can take a lot of work to accurately predict how long it will take to complete each phase of the project.

Agile methodology

Agile software development is a process-oriented approach to software development that focuses on flexibility and responsiveness. Instead of following a linear, sequential path, agile development focuses on delivering iterative releases in short cycles, allowing for more frequent updates and changes. The agile method can be divided into planning, design, development, testing, release, and feedback cycles.

Advantages of the Agile Methodology

  • It allows for a great deal of flexibility and adaptability. This makes it ideal for large and complex projects with rapidly changing customer requirements.
  • It also encourages collaboration between developers, testers, and stakeholders.

Disadvantages of the Agile Methodology

  • It can be hard to keep up with the constant changes and updates.
  • Additionally, some teams struggle with the lack of structure and discipline that agile methodology provides.
  • The project can go off-course if the customer is not clear about their requirements.

Verification and Validation Methodology (V-Model)

The verification and validation (V-model) is a testing methodology that follows a linear progression from requirements to tests. This model starts with the definition of customer requirements, followed by design, coding, and testing. Each step is verified and validated against the customer’s requirements to ensure accuracy. It is considered to be a superior model to waterfall testing. The V-method can be divided into four major steps: unit testing, integration testing, system testing, and acceptance testing.

Advantages of the V-model

  • The V-model is structured and highly organised, making it easy to track progress.
  • It ensures that all requirements have been met before the software is released.

Disadvantages of the V-model

  • It is a rigid model
  • It can be difficult to make changes or adapt to customer requirements once a step has been completed.
  • It can be time-consuming and costly to implement.

Spiral Methodology

The spiral methodology is an iterative software development process that combines elements of the waterfall model and agile methodology. It allows for flexibility but still follows a structured process. This model works best for large and complex projects with high levels of risk. The spiral model consists of four major steps: planning, risk analysis, evaluation, and engineering.

Advantages of the Spiral Methodology

  • It allows for frequent reviews and updates.
  • It is ideal for projects with high levels of risk since it allows for changes to be made as the project progresses.

Disadvantages of the Spiral Methodology

  • The complexity of the process can make it difficult to manage.
  • It can be time-consuming and costly to implement.
  • It can also be hard to track progress since each iteration is essentially a miniature project.

Iterative Model

An iterative model is an incremental approach to software development that focuses on delivering small chunks of functionality over time. It allows for flexibility and adaptability and encourages frequent feedback from stakeholders. The iterative model consists of five components: analysis, design, coding, testing, and implementation.

Advantages of the Iterative Model

  • The incremental approach allows for more flexibility and adaptability than waterfall or agile.
  • It also encourages frequent feedback from stakeholders, allowing for changes and modifications as the project progresses.

Disadvantages of the Iterative Model

  • It can be difficult to manage due to the complexity of the process.
  • It can also be hard to allocate resources and track progress since each iteration is essentially a separate project.
  • It can also be costly and time-consuming to implement.

Which Method to Use for Your Software Testing Project?

When it comes to software testing, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. The best software testing method for your project depends on the size, complexity, and timeline of the project. If you have a large and complex project with high levels of risk, the spiral methodology may be your best option. For smaller projects with limited time and resources, the agile or iterative model may be more suitable. Ultimately, the best software testing method for your project is the one that fits your unique needs and goals.


No matter which method you choose, it is important to understand the advantages and disadvantages of each before deciding. This will help ensure that your project runs smoothly and you get the best results.

If you need more help deciding which software testing method is best for your project, contact an experienced software testing service provider, such as ImpactAQ. We can help you create a customised plan tailored to your project needs and goals, ensuring that your software is tested efficiently and effectively. Get in touch today to learn more about our services.


Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the latest industry news, case studies, blogs and updates directly to your inbox

3+3 =